|              MOSCOW, Dec. 24 - By its             own admission, Russia's electricity monopoly is the world's largest             corporate producer of greenhouse gases, accounting - by itself - for             nearly as much carbon dioxide as is emitted by Britain.              From smokestacks across             Russia's 11 time zones, the company, Unified Energy Systems, spews             out 2 percent of all human-generated carbon dioxide accumulating in             the atmosphere.             What will the utility get             for being the world's largest greenhouse gas polluter? It is hoping             for $1 billion.              It is one of the paradoxes             of the Kyoto Protocol on climate change that companies in Russia and             other Eastern European countries, which are among the world's             largest producers of greenhouse gases, are poised to earn hundreds             of millions of dollars through trading their rights to release             carbon dioxide into the air.              The Kyoto treaty,             negotiated in 1997 and adopted by 36 industrial nations, established             a mechanism aimed at finding the cheapest way to curb emissions of             gases that contribute to global warming. The idea was that countries             that produced more than their treaty-imposed limits could reach             their goals by buying rights from producers in other countries where             controlling output is easier and less expensive.              It is not clear how             successful that approach will turn out to be. But because Russia's             companies operate such outdated and inefficient equipment, they can             easily and cheaply upgrade. As a result, the Kyoto process has             already emerged as a potential source of earnings for the country's             big energy and manufacturing companies, according to company             executives and analysts. They have hired consultants, inventoried             pollution sources to earn credits, and opened carbon-trading             divisions.              Unified Energy and Gazprom,             Russia's natural gas monopoly, which together release more than 50             percent of greenhouse gas emissions in Russia, both have such             trading units.              "We're intensely interested             in the carbon-trading market," Andrey V. Gorkov, the head of the             carbon-trading division at Unified Energy, said earlier this month             in Montreal, where he was attending the United Nations climate             conference. Member countries formally approved emissions-trading             rules at the meeting.              The protocol requires the             36 industrial nations - with varying targets - to reduce their             emissions of greenhouse gases below their 1990 levels, in the five             years from 2008 to 2012.              For the European Union, the             target is to reduce emissions to 8 percent below 1990 levels. In an             indication of how robust the demand for emissions credits may be,             this year the European Union is 6 percent above its 1990 levels. The             United States, which generates a fifth of greenhouse gases but has             not joined the Kyoto Protocol, is 19 percent above its theoretical             limits.              Russia, in contrast,             suffered an economic collapse in the 1990's, and is 43 percent below             its 1990 baseline in the Kyoto agreement. In fact, Russia does not             expect to reach 1990's emissions levels until around 2020 -             attesting to the severity of the economic setback from which it is             still recovering.              At the same time, Russian             industry is generally wasteful with energy, so that a few cheap             upgrades go a long way to reducing emissions. Thus, with both             outdated equipment and a surplus of carbon emissions, Russian             companies have become attractive to European, Canadian and Japanese             companies that need emissions credits.              The pace is increasing at             Mr. Gorkov's cluttered office in Unified Energy headquarters, a drab             concrete building on the outskirts of Moscow. Analysts give credit             to the company's forward-looking chief executive, Anatoly B.             Chubais, for recognizing the potential for profits under Kyoto. Mr.             Chubais, a former deputy prime minister, had helped negotiate the             pact while in government.              Mr. Gorkov's 16 employees             at the division, which is called the Energy Carbon Fund, scan the             Internet for companies or countries in need of carbon dioxide             emissions credits. They also study their own company to identify             areas where they can reduce pollution. The company signed its first             deal in June, with the environmental protection agency of Denmark.                          Denmark will pay an             undisclosed sum for Unified Energy to replace coal-fired boilers at             the Amurskaya power plant in Khabarovsk, near China in eastern             Siberia, so that units will burn more efficient natural gas. It will             also pay to upgrade an existing natural gas plant in the Orenburg             region, in southern Russia near Kazakhstan, with a more efficient             model.              The conversion to gas at             the Amurskaya plant will cut carbon dioxide emissions by a million             tons a year, according to Unified Energy. The upgrading of the             natural gas generator at the Mednogorskaya power plant in Orenburg             will save 210,000 tons.              Under the deal, the Danish             government will receive 1.2 million carbon credits (one carbon             credit being equal to reducing one ton of carbon dioxide), to be             applied toward meeting its emissions goal in 2012.             This fall, six other             clients from Europe and Japan also lined up to buy emissions credits             from Unified Energy, Mr. Gorkov said. The Toyota Corporation of Japan is             co-financing studies at one plant, and may pay for upgrades,             according to a Unified Energy Systems statement.              Gazprom, Russia's largest             company, is studying ways to attract Kyoto financing to upgrade             other pipelines, said Bogdan Budzulyak, director of the company's             transportation and underground storage department.              Midsize Russian companies             are also eyeing the emissions market.              The Arkhangelsk Pulp and             Paper Mill, with revenues of about $250 million a year, has said it             will monitor emissions, according to an article in the August 2005             issue of Carbon Finance, a trade publication.              In total, Russia could             potentially reduce emissions by two billion to three billion tons of             carbon dioxide by 2012, said Alexander A. Golub, a senior economist             at Environmental Defense, a nonprofit group based in New York. The             potential value for Russia ranges from $20 billion to $60 billion,             he said. Or it could be worth nothing, if future climate talks             collapse. The United States, the world's largest economy, is already             sitting out the process.              President Bush rejected the             Kyoto Protocol in 2001, citing the high cost to American industry.             Now, without the support of the world's largest economy, there is             less chance other countries will agree to extend the treaty beyond             2012. Companies must decide if it is worth investing millions of             dollars to comply with an international regulatory regime that may             not be enforced after 2012 - and may collapse before then.             "Discussions over the             future of the Kyoto Protocol are affecting our market," Mr. Gorkov             said.              Even so, emissions trading             has been slowed in Russia more by the sluggish pace of government             bureaucracy than by uncertainty over the Kyoto Protocol.              The Danish deal was signed             in June. It hinged on the Russian government passing a decree to             endorse Kyoto trading. That was due in late November, but delayed             until February, according to an e-mail message from Hans J. Eriksen,             the program coordinator at the Danish environmental ministry.                          Annie Petsonk,             international counsel for Environmental Defense, said: "This is             quite a new commodity for Russia. Maybe they don't understand that             Russia has tremendous potential."              Both Gazprom and             Unified Energy have issued statements urging the Russian government             to enforce Kyoto as quickly as possible. In the United States, in             contrast, Exxon Mobil led corporate opposition to Kyoto.                          In Russia, the Ministry of             Trade and Economic Development has formed a working group to study             the decree. It needs to clear various agencies and committees.             Russian officials sent a letter of apology to the Danish ministry in             November.              Meanwhile, at Unified             Energy, where the order book for pollution credit projects is             stacking up, Mr. Gorkov is getting impatient. "We needed this             document signed yesterday," he       said.  |